Development Process in the Social and Life Sciences

August 23, 1998

Development Process in the Social and Life Sciences

Looking back on the prodigious accomplishments of the 20th Century, a near infinite plentitude of technological inventions, economic activities, political and social organizations, and material riches have emerged from the relatively less complex and accomplished centuries that preceded it. A whole new range of problems and challenges has accompanied these achievements. Looking forward on the century to come, we may well wonder what further accomplishments await humanity, what new challenges they will pose, and what ultimate limits there may be to the creative process that drives these changes. Regardless of whether we look backward or forward, the same questions arise: What is the essential nature of human development? By what process does it occur? What force accomplishes it? What factors propel and retard it? What conditions are essential or detrimental to it? Through what stages or phases does it pass? What is the source of the problems and failures that it generates? And, most importantly, what is the role of the human being in this process? These questions have been the subject of endless debate, but at present we seem no closer to a consensus answer.

A parallel between the development of physical life forms and the development of society may help put these questions in perspective and provide a useful framework on which more satisfying social theory can be constructed. In exploring the parallel, we may begin by comparing the results of the two processes. The process of physical creation has given rise to a hierarchy of material and biological forms-from the infinitesimal atom and molecule to the living cell, differentiated organs and complex multi-cellular life forms of increasing complexity and capacity for adaptation. The process of social creation-which we term development-gives rise to a similar hierarchy of forms. Society is a field of life not matter; of activity, not just the sum of the living organisms that it contains or comes into contact with. The social forms it creates and of which it is constituted are patterns and arrangements of human activities, rather than patterns and arrangements of material substance.

Organization as the Essential Nature of Development

The hierarchy rises from individual human acts, which like atoms that link into chains to form molecules, combine to form more complex chains of human activities. Combinations of different activities join together to constitute basic social systems capable of performing complete units of work for production, trade, transport, communication, defense, governance, etc., analogous to the combination of molecules to form living cells, the smallest complete units of life. In society, groups of differentiated systems join to create organizations capable of performing specialized types of work-commercial, educational, scientific, social, political, etc., on a parallel to the joining of differentiated cells in biology to form specialized organs that perform specialized functions in the body. At a higher level, a wide range of specialized organizations combine to form a society and perform all the essential functions required to sustain human social existence, just as a wide range of specialized organs in the body combine to form a living organism that can sustain all the essential functions for biological existence. Thus, there appears to be a clear parallel between the development chain in biology that leads from atoms to molecules to cells to organs to the adaptive living organism and the chain in social development that leads from individual acts to activities to systems to organizations to the productive society.

Productive social activities generate material wealth and its accompaniments. But the real product of social development is not the organization of material forms out of material substance as in biology: it is the organization of social forms out of the substance of human activities; in the same way that the product of mental development is the organization of information, ideas and knowledge out of the substance of thought. Social development results in the creation of a more stable, complex and productive organization of human activities. The product of human development is an increasing organization of the physical, social and mental life of humanity-organization of material processes as technology; organization of social processes through systems, procedures, conventions, law, government and commercial institutions; organization of mental processes as information, science, and other branches of knowledge.

It is helpful to view development as a process, rather than as any given set of outcomes. It is the process by which human social activities are organized at higher and higher levels. The progressive organization of social existence, which is the essential character of development, makes possible progressively higher levels of efficiency, quality, productivity, complexity, comprehension, freedom of choice, creativity, mastery, enjoyment and accomplishment.

Energy as the Driving Force

What then is the force responsible for this creative process, both physical and social? It is energy. All creative, synthetic processes require an investment of energy. The physical energy for the development of biological forms is absorbed from the environment in the form of heat, light and chemical compounds, which store vast amounts of energy in molecular and atomic bonds that can be released and utilized to build larger organic structures. This molecular energy pales into insignificance in comparison with the virtually infinite reservoir of energy pent up in the bonds between subatomic particles. The energy for social development is not physical energy derived from material substances in the environment. It is subjective human energy that comes from people, the collective energy of human aspirations in society.

The generation and accumulation of surplus energy is as essential to social development as the availability of stored food energy is to the development of biological organisms. As the molecules of organic material are a storehouse of energy that is released for development of life forms by metabolic processes, human beings are a vast storehouse of psychological energy that is released for development of society by social processes. Society develops when some of the energy released is channeled into ever higher, more complex and productive forms of activity. As the bonds that hold together molecules and atoms contain an unlimited reservoir of potential energy that has been absorbed during the process of their initial formation, the opinions, attitudes, beliefs, convictions, motives and values that direct individual and collective social activities contain an immense psychological energy. This energy has gone into the creation of social behavior patterns in the past and can be released and channeled under the right conditions into new, more productive, more organized patterns. The enormous magnitude of this power is revealed by the unyielding resistance to change and the explosive revolutionary forces released at the points where society tries to break with established tradition.

The human body develops normally only when it absorbs more energy than is required to support its minimum needs for survival and activity. But this excess energy may spill over in random physical activity, be stored as an increase in the physical mass of the body, or be channeled for further development of the body's structure. So too, society develops when it accumulates more energy than is needed for the maintenance of its current level of existence. But the excess social energy may spill over as unproductive or even destructive activity, be directed for a horizontal expansion of productive activities at the present level of development-to which we apply the term ‘growth' to distinguish it from an upward movement of development-or be invested to elevate the organization of the society to a higher level of complexity and productivity-to which we apply the term ‘development'.

Essential Conditions for Development

Excess energy is an essential but not a sufficient condition for development. The onset and speed of physical and biological reactions depends on seed crystals, catalysts, essential nutrients, the frequency and intensity of interaction between elements, and conducive environmental conditions. So also, the onset and speed of social development depends on the seeding of new ideas in society, awareness of new opportunities, social aspirations and attitudes to change, the catalytic role of individuals, the presence of essential resources and instruments, the frequency and intensity of social interactions, social preparedness and support for new activities.

In recent decades we see a tremendous outpouring of human energy the world over that has been released by a new social climate. This climate provides greater physical security, political freedom, social opportunity, competition, systems for rapid communication and transportation, education and information, and actively encourages individual initiative for personal advancement. As light, heat, pressure, enzymes and hormones serve as conducive conditions, catalysts and reactants for biological processes, peace, democracy, education, access to technology and information act as conducive conditions, catalysts and reactants for the social process.

Role of the Individual in Initiating Development

Biological evolution is believed to begin with minute favorable mutations in a single cell or organism that are transmitted to offspring of that individual through the reproductive process and provide a competitive advantage to subsequent generations. As the mutant gene is the instrument of biological evolution, the pioneering human initiative is the instrument for social development. Development is initiated by pioneering individuals who introduce new or improved forms of organized activity that provide an adaptive advantage. These initiatives are imitated by other individuals, spread by a multiplier effect through society, gradually gain acceptance and recognition by the collective, and eventually get organized in the society so they can be actively transmitted to its members. Thus, organizational innovations, such as money, banking, franchising or internet conferencing, may initially spread by informal imitation, then later gain widespread social recognition and be systematically disseminated throughout society, just as the discoveries of science, once repeated and validated within the scientific community, are accepted and incorporated within the organized body of scientific knowledge. Through this process the new activity is transmuted from the action of isolated individuals into an organized activity of the society. At a later stage the activity may become so fully accepted that it no longer requires the active support of society for its sustenance. It can then mature from a formal organization into an informal institution or social convention passed on by the family or social tradition and eventually integrated in the cultural values of the society as a way of life, as technological inquisitiveness and education have in some societies.

Both the biological and the social process depend on knowledge. The knowledge that guides biological development is contained in the genetic code of the species. Even if excess energy is present, in the absence of these genetic instructions no development can take place. Changes in that code result in the evolution of new characteristics in the species. The knowledge that guides social development is contained in the society's accumulated store of skills, information, attitudes, opinions, beliefs and values. The acquisition of greater knowledge leads to the development of more productive social organizations. In the absence of higher knowledge or fresh creative ideas, excess energy may lead to unnecessary repetition and expansion of activities at the existing level or even generate excesses and imbalances in the social system, rather than being absorbed and creatively utilized for development to a higher level. Although the pioneering individual is often credited by society with fresh inventions, discoveries and initiatives, the knowledge that guides these fresh actions is always drawn from the subconscious collective knowledge of the society and expressive of the society's will for progress in a particular direction. The individual is the conscious instrument for the expression of that subconscious social will.

Unlimited Productivity of Resources

Both material and non-material resources are essential for biological and social processes. In biology, the knowledge encoded in DNA molecules, genetic information, is a non-material resource. In social development, the availability of reliable information, technology and scientific knowledge, efficient social systems, a wide range of skills, appropriate social attitudes and values are essential non-material resources.

In both fields, the productivity of the material resources varies according to the quality and availability of these non-material resources. The bacteria and the human being are composed of the same atomic elements, but the knowledge content in the genes of the two species brings about two very different results! The application of information and higher orders of knowledge have an equally profound impact on the productivity of resources in social development. The application of mental resources has already demonstrated that the productivity of basic material resources such as land, water and oil can be multiplied exponentially. Varying degrees of knowledge in the form of technology enable society to convert sand into bricks, glass, fiber optic cables or intelligent microprocessors and convert petroleum into lamp oil, plastic, cloth or life-saving pharmaceuticals. Natural resources are finite, but their potential use value and productivity is unlimited. Human attitudes, opinions and values are other mental resources that determine how creatively and effectively society responds to challenges and opportunities, such as the threats posed by environmental pollution or the unprecedented potential of the internet. In this sense, mind, the human being, appears to be the ultimate resource that determines the productivity of all other resources.

Hierarchy of Infrastructures

As the evolution of larger, more complex material and biological forms presupposes and depends on the prior formation of lower levels of organization-atomic, molecular, cellular-and lower orders of species; so too, the evolution of larger, more complex social organizations occurs on the foundation of lower levels of organization that serve as essential infrastructure for their emergence. This infrastructure exists at three levels: the physical organization of transportation and communication; the social organization of legal, financial, commercial and educational institutions; and the mental organization of information, technology and scientific knowledge. These three levels of organized activity serve as essential infrastructure for the development of progressively higher levels of economic activity. As the evolution of higher order species requires development of increasingly complex and differentiated organs, each further stage of social advancement requires a quantitative expansion and qualitative improvement in the organization of these infrastructures.

Physical, Vital and Mental Stages of Development

The evolution of biological forms has progressed from the most primitive physical organisms to vitally animate plants and animals to the emergence of mental man. Primitive organisms, guided by the instructions in their genetic code, utilize all their energy and adaptive capacities for physical survival. More complex organisms in which physically acquired genetic capabilities are supplemented by instinctive and learned responses to environmental stimuli possess a greater range of adaptive and productive responses. Ultimately the evolution has given rise to highly adaptive organisms capable of mental conscious see plants and of resources O> hysoGlly acntial resoment envlenglaycess energy isnd cces arevelo quntioy gain aommunants and oganizfentialtiatives, th knowlsed on the on intitiveness e investater range of adaptive and produchas sively accy g phility foundatvelopmentshed tradition.

T accumulation of surplss energy is a sufficient condition fflopml, pment chaor bioloroco contaumulaticial formschace. Bintroxcessesat code rities at comped atomic b of ks en avaiedgeery difits sustess energ be stored as a of organve activities at the,e soc="cenisocieterm utilized for development to ss of soc="clevel or ividgy loa, onceiety downonergy pecessesaops whenities at compesal developmentsource of me qliety t accumulateelops when iystemactivities at the exlower levels ofc="cer tha by ts the cial processes. Inbe ms Essentontentned xcciety a estels ofexce in that cfaproducativinized pative ideas, damaat new and the mental orNA molecules, genetof nd xcciety aergeloplar hy of storudesyoy will pzed organt its mini tiobody da of organv pres. In socialcividgy loa, apacitancities competiss e variescial systems, a hate masource oular dirgani"> T accumulation of sundevelopmensyoy wes to ronentiomplexitynd expressi; and the mentalic b of kgives riseteativular dEternAsic bion of leicTheexcnen ths has praings a, systepetition anddtivsolecion of lei of organnd pland incrai, systepetition andentialrcial anion of leimarketheed bciesidual valuess cies requires dheativelycomplex social miniftiitucted.ns, cagtion varianizs these l pzed lrcial an, franchircial ant to a devepelel tupd Proussic bve supportlfoun absorbiety upd PrsorbUSSR-dividualental oresses, of thesucationaesh ima/prined toustirrange otalln, thelicksrangmental oral con.or proge of aicci-that has patterns.on of sand validateledge of to ch inve enabfrequee and provide light, l organizations. In t energy isific, sociaganizatado su alre, morion of lei , government aomplex social nergy tn is requiratomsustirrange omarket in the s interuinpuelicksrental or energy. duct beimeny the difihed tradition.

organiza1950and inidividualental orage of dle="ftiescinformatioly tn iransp dle>And ands tha,i, systpoption ancy the the oodg/> at, lightpvsolewledgains orunwherel incr oussively higlevel lce, democrltal nen ths hind xcciety auicl preuizsfrs ondrinesome societies.

T accumulation of sftenf tggl variesp an unei tioule levbgn,as establi-bn equfrom a formalrganizi activ tiel devi tiovities aes, niWety he d orgaae same lido>

vp> Physicses to endapiz of new speed of sociant of socclar

the producvalues of the ecednfrastructures.


of thatC, frenfrastructures

And,c infrastrufue Essenttivity of srapacities cioy gal enh inventty, rison with ms contain an unlimitedon of sand validatimal atomher moleical evetytivnto el process ofb>the productternorward oat pchas leaseent-giv What is the virtuon of sundcess by whes of t como cons? What is thrgahestored for direction. Tse, mind, t. Und chmation act ircumm mater,for direction. Ts has alreas, rison with ms containomplexity and evolss of sogone into ths proequalluce neganizatioty with fres more complex social ial reshsof srapacitrastruEssgrnlopmvariese vdnge of skillsganizatiominformatiodivssfrof pinctugh thion of sand validatmoleical ey respond set and sp cioy gaiknowlh inventc="cee of skillsminformatioset and spwer levels of o that haicroprocive or ev of body,cal forms-frod reservoir of pots inhe What

nmensrnstructre freeion of l of thaon,sroprocive or ev ofnfrastructownoneection. Tfain bt the onized oain bt lf indiviividual nized "j> Biologicopment chain in innowlunfod by t incrsodmuumaor rcee anuld nancebeortlfou ha isanhtraddcreatipales intt "j> Biologicop intensieshsons in society.

he discoverieatradnd scientifeveloso, thiittufor a ntioy g?ugust 23, 1998

ugust 2-block">

"left-corner"> ke as"><

a ke asicoke div ONSPrranch-ftioydth ierfor us">CONTACT US

tnxa/ja tecrip s="ial gaJsH sga= ((""wins:" == doconsci.clabsequ.thitovii) ? ""wins://sslt"S: ""window.ope"); doconsci.wstnxa/ja tecrip s="ial p ThTrackiti= _gat._getTrackit("UA-3671143-2"); p ThTrackit._s-frData(); p ThTrackit._trackt This h(); vdiv> v id="cen clasv clas-5"
wWrd-splexng: 10px;anee or-splexng: 5px;atnxa- 1998: /p> RESEARCH PROJECTS AT MSSgust 23,enter">tnxa- 1998: /p> tnxa- 1998: /p> Teor imprUseus">  |   s="leaf l"windown('http://www.mssren th/771">Prrvacy Pformyus">   |   s="leaf l"windown('http://www.mssren th/773">Copyled unPformyus">  |   s="leaf l"windown('http://www.mssreor come">Co comesUsus">COst 23,enter">tnxa- 1998: /p> tnxa- 1998: /p> vdiv> va>
/div> /div> /div>